When removing started with a intelligent home, a intelligent orator is ordinarily a place to begin. With 3 vital contenders on a market—Amazon Echo (2nd Gen), Apple HomePod, and Google Home—you’ll wish to know what creates them opposite to figure out that is right for you.
Here, we review these speakers in design, price, intelligence, accessories, audio quality, and privacy. It’s Apple HomePod vs. Google Home vs. Amazon Echo: May a best orator win.
Apple HomePod vs Google Home vs Amazon Echo: Design
Amazon Echo (2nd Generation) looks like a stout cylinder. At 5.7 inches, it’s shorter than a strange Echo. It has a many options for selecting a style. You can get a fabric finish in charcoal, heather gray, or sandstone, or a timber finish in ash or walnut. You can mislay and change out a extraneous bombard with these opposite options.
Apple HomePod looks like a fat cylinder with dull edges. The fabric extraneous comes in space gray or white. It’s hefty, weighing 5.5 pounds and measures 6.8 inches high.
- Google Home vs. Google Home Mini: Which is better?
- Apple HomePod vs. Google Home: What’s a difference?
- What is Apple TV and is it value it?
Google Home looks like an oversized atmosphere freshener: a wide, turn bottom tapers to an pointed top. The bottom is swappable, so for an additional cost, we can change a tone and texture. Google Home measures usually 5.62 inches tall, creation it a smallest of a three.
Design matters when shopping a intelligent orator since we can’t usually censor it in a dilemma of a room. For it to work properly, it contingency be divided from walls so that it can hear you. Be certain to collect something we don’t mind carrying on display.
Apple HomePod vs Google Home vs Amazon Echo: Price
Here’s how a 3 speakers review in price:
- Amazon Echo 2nd generation: $99.99
- Apple HomePod: $349.00
- Google Home: $129.00
Those total are for a customary models. We can also review a prices of other accessible models that have a same comprehension inside them. These operation from inexpensive “mini” products to some-more expensive, reward versions. They are:
- Amazon Echo Dot 3rd gen (hockey puck-looking device): $49
- Google Mini (hockey puck-looking device): $49
- Amazon Echo Spot (small turn section with tiny display): $129.99
- Amazon Echo Plus (improved audio): $149.99
- Google Home Hub (tablet-sized display): $149
- Amazon Echo Show (tablet-sized display): $229.99
- Google Home Max (improved audio): $399
At this time, Apple usually sells one intelligent speaker.
Amazon Echo vs Apple HomePod vs Google Home: Intelligence
Each intelligent partner has a strengths and weaknesses when it comes to executing commands. For example, Alexa is unsurprisingly skilful during assisting we buy things on Amazon. Google Assistant is best during acid for information. In a debility category, Apple HomePod can hardly control an Apple TV, usually pause, resume, and adjust a volume.
The good thing about all these intelligent assistance, however, is that we can exam them out before we buy a speaker. The program that powers a comprehension lives in a cloud rather than being stored locally. So while we can get it by a speaker, we can also get it on your phone or tablet.
If we wish to try Siri, we can glow it adult on an iOS or macOS device. There’s a Google Assistant app for Android and iOS; it’s also built into many Android phones. Even Alexa now comes in a form of an app for iOS and Android. So try out these apps for yourself before spending some-more than $100 on a device.
Amazon Echo vs Apple HomePod vs Google Home: Accessories
Amazon Echo has a prolonged list of products that work with it, presumably a longest of a three. That’s partly due to a fact that a Echo has been on a marketplace longer than a other two. Echo accessories cover all a obvious brands, from Philips to Nest. With the best Amazon Echo accessories, we can authority your Roomba to vacuum, H2O your lawn, get insights about your health and activity (through Fitbit), and more. Because Echo is finished by Amazon, it works good with other Amazon products, such as a indoor notice camera Amazon Cloud Cam.
Google Home’s accessories preference is solid, too, yet smaller than Amazon’s. Seeing as this intelligent orator is from Google, it works with other Google devices, such as Chromecast. While it might not support all underneath a sun, it covers all a vital bases in a intelligent home field. You can buy intelligent thatch by August, a Nest thermostat, Philips light bulbs, as good as inclination from ecobee, Honeywell, and others.
Apple HomePod has a healthy preference of accessories, yet expected a fewest of a three. Of a 3 companies, however, Apple does a best pursuit of presenting a one list of devices that work with Apple HomeKit. You can try and hunt that list for whatever appendage you’re meddlesome in buying. There are a few vital brands that now do not have Apple HomePod-compatible devices: Nest, Roomba, and SmartThings.
Amazon Echo vs Apple HomePod vs Google Home: Audio quality
Comparing a bottom models only—i.e., incompatible reward models such as Google Home Max—Apple HomePod consistently gets some-more regard for a audio peculiarity than Amazon Echo (2nd Gen) or Google Home.
Apple proudly shows off a HomePod’s high-excursion woofer and set of 7 horn-loaded tweeters, any with a tradition amplifier. In easier terms, it’s absolute adequate to make song sound good, though losing drum or sounding tinny. The HomePod also has facilities that presumably adjust aspects of a audio to comment for division from a speaker’s surroundings.
Amazon’s Echo (2nd Gen) has a 2.5-inch downward-firing woofer and 0.6-inch tweeter, giving it really good audio quality. Many contend a 2nd Gen Echo has identical or somewhat softened audio peculiarity than a initial Echo. It might not be a powerhouse of speakers, though it gets a pursuit done.
Google Home contains a high outing orator with 2-inch motorist and twin 2-inch pacifist radiators. Reviewers contend Google Home has good peculiarity audio for listening to oral information and podcasts, as good as personification song casually. But it’s substantially a weakest of a 3 when it comes to capturing a full brilliance of music.
Amazon Echo vs Apple HomePod vs Google Home: Privacy
Based on how a orator creates requests for information, Apple has stronger remoteness than Google or Amazon. But due to how it works, HomePod is somewhat reduction available than a Echo or Google Home.
With Google Home and Amazon Echo, all we say, request, and buy gets compared with your Google or Amazon account. The speakers commend opposite voices. If we ask Google Assistant or Alexa for information that’s specific to you, such as how prolonged your invert will be, it knows your voice and therefore knows what invert addresses we have saved in your account. As such, it can broach information that’s specific to you.
Because Google Assistant and Alexa commend opposite voices, mixed people in your home can use a speaker. Their information stays apart from yours.
There are some downsides to differentiating who’s speaking. If a supervision subpoenaed Google or Amazon for a record of all you’ve pronounced and finished with it, a companies technically have those annals and could give them up. (Whether they would is another matter.) The indicate is, a information record exists that’s specific to you.
Apple does not use a personal form when we speak to HomePod. It doesn’t emanate a record of information about all we say. Instead, when we ask HomePod something, Siri creates a ask to a cloud regulating a pointless identifier. If Apple had to come adult with a list of all you’ve pronounced to HomePod, it would be scarcely unfit since a association has no approach of meaningful that of a pointless identifiers belongs to you.
The disastrous side of this setup, however, is that HomePod does not heed voices. If your roommate says, “Siri. Play my voicemails,” HomePod will play your messages. You can configure your settings to restrict a personal information HomePod can access, that is substantially a intelligent move.
Which intelligent orator is right for you?
In comparing a facilities that matter many to you, that orator comes out on top? Here’s what I’d recommend:
- Amazon Echo (2nd Gen) casts a widest net in a appeal. A rival cost keeps it within strech for many households. It supports an huge list of concordant inclination for building out your intelligent home. The audio peculiarity should sufficient for many needs. Swappable exteriors let we change a look.
- Apple HomePod is best for people who have some remoteness concerns, wish a many absolute audio experience, and don’t mind spending $349.
- Google Home seems a many able in terms of returning hunt results. It shares a lot of similarities with Amazon Echo and is a best choice if you’re simply against to Amazon products (hey, no visualisation there). Its low cost also helps to make it an appealing option.