Samsung Galaxy S8: The good, a bad, a beautiful
A stunning, winding arrangement and glorious camera accommodate an ungainly fingerprint reader and work-in-progress digital assistant.
Once again, Samsung and LG’s opposition phones come face to face. And once again, we’re here to assistance we figure out that is best for you.
Both a Galaxy S8 and G6 are glorious high-end phones with slim bezels, waterproofing and a latest Android 7.0 software. And both companies are attempting to recover their change after eccentric setbacks; Samsung from a Galaxy Note 7 remember calamity and LG from a nonstarter that was a LG G5 and a handful of modular accessories.
Overall, a S8 has a sexier, stronger hardware, nonetheless does that unequivocally matter in a end? LG’s G6 saves we income and offers a lot of a same features. To assistance we out, we evaluated how these inclination built adult in design, camera, performance, facilities and value.
Design: Eye-candy and durability
The S8 and G6 have copiousness of pattern elements in common. Both are rated IP68 for H2O insurgency and have barely-there bezels. However, a S8 has a somewhat bigger arrangement (5.8 inches compared to 5.7), and is physically lighter, narrower and thinner than a G6. It also fared improved during a dump test. The S8’s arrangement uses Corning Gorilla Glass 5 and survived mixed drops from opposite heights. But a G6’s shade is coated with Gorilla Glass 3 and during a dump tests, it burst on a initial try. Lastly, a S8’s arrangement has a aloft pixel density, so it’s a tad crook (though we can’t unequivocally discern this with your exposed eye).
One thing that we positively hatred about a S8, though, is a fingerprint reader, that is awkwardly located right subsequent to a camera lens. we many cite a G6’s approach, that places a turn aim right underneath a camera lens.
Winner: The S8. While we rebuff a plcae of a S8’s fingerprint sensor, a phone is sleeker and some-more pleasing than a G6.
Camera: Capturing pleasing pics and video
The G6 can take wide-angle shots from a front-facing camera and dual back cameras (one’s got a wide-angle lens). This means we can fit some-more calm in any frame, including some-more peeps for a organisation selfie. There’s also a Square Camera app that edits neat block photos ideal for Instagram.
The S8 does not have dual back cameras (bucking the trend that Apple, LG and Huawei have all hopped on), nonetheless it has tons of facilities like Snapchat-like facial effects and a Portrait modifying choice that blurs a background.
As for print quality, both phones take pointy and splendid pictures. And while we was tender by a G6’s white change and tone correctness for dimly illuminated photos, a S8 did a improved pursuit during lighting adult a dim shots in general. The S8 also took some-more tangible selfies, and we elite a S8’s deeper contrasts. (You can check out some-more of a G6’s print peculiarity with a gallery below. And peruse a S8’s camera gallery here.)
Winner: You’ll positively be confident with possibly phones’ cameras, and a G6’s wide-angle choice can come in handy. But we was some-more tender by a S8’s print quality.
Performance: Processor speeds and battery life
Given a some-more modernized Snapdragon 835 chipset, a S8 tallied adult aloft scores on all 3 benchmarks we conducted opposite a G6 and a 821 chipset (you can see a Antutu, Geekbench and 3DMark results here). But usually given a S8 is faster on paper doesn’t meant you’ll see any imbecility from a G6. Indeed, both are as rapid and discerning with real-life usage, like scrolling by web pages, rising apps and gnawing photos.
As for battery life, a S8’s reduce ability 3,000mAh battery (compared to a G6’s 3,300mAh) outlasted a G6 by scarcely 3 hours in a drainage exam for continual video playback on Airplane mode. It clocked in 16 hours compared to a G6’s 13.
Winner: The Galaxy S8, easily. The G6 unequivocally isn’t a slump — a processor is still arguable and fast, and a battery life is excellent. But it usually couldn’t overtake a S8 on both accounts.
Features: Interface and program goodies
Both a interfaces on a G6 and S8 are essential and easy to understand. While I’m not feeling a dull corners for a app icons (it looks dated) from both phones, any objections we have about aesthetics can be fast bound with a new launcher and idol pack.
The S8 throws in a add-on we can lift out to entrance things like your most-used apps and contacts, a continue and calendar events. we found it minimally useful, nonetheless nonessential.
The S8 also has a digital voice partner named Bixby. While it has other facilities like scanning and retrieving info from objects in genuine life, it’s not entirely fleshed out nonetheless and Samsung is still operative on a development. For a meantime, we can use Google Assistant, that comes built-in on both phones.
Winner: This is a tie for me. we like a additional facilities a S8 offers along a edge, nonetheless unless you’re an zealous fan and user of these panels (and I’m not), both phones are flattering on customary with one another.
Value: Most crash for your buck
Across mixed carriers and countries, a G6 is consistently cheaper than a S8. In a US, this disproportion can operation from $30 to $100. In a UK and Australia, there’s about a £40 and AU$191 difference, respectively. Keep in mind that a S8 comes with twice as many built-in storage (64GB compared to a G6’s 32GB), nonetheless both phones have expandable storage adult to 2TB.
True, a cost disproportion between a dual isn’t outrageous (compared to, say, a assets you’d get if we bought a OnePlus 3T or others), nonetheless $100 is still a critical volume of mix to keep in your wallet — generally if you’re on a parsimonious budget.
Winner: The G6 is a one to get if we wish to save cash. (#Protip: There might be some G6 deals still going on that embody a giveaway Google Home or LG TV.)
Class movement lawsuits: Who’s removing sued over what (*bonus round!)
As a PSA, we combined a reward turn about a lawsuits both companies are traffic with surrounding their devices. If you’ve been vital underneath a stone via 2016 (and who could censure you), Samsung gifted a large failure when some of a Galaxy Note 7s exploded, and Samsung had to remember a phone. As such, lots of people are suing for payment and use fees.
Not to be outdone, there’s a category movement lawsuit being brought opposite LG for a bootlooping issue with a G4 and V10 phones. Not usually were some of these handsets bricked, LG is indicted of not doing adequate to repay and reinstate these inadequate products.
To be fair, these complaints and issues are being lobbied opposite past devices, and a S8 and G6 demeanour to be behaving a-okay so far. But we have a right to be heedful about these company’s past troubles, given you’re handing over your hard-earned income after all.
Winner: Nobody! Particularly you, a consumer.
And a leader is…
Taking home design, camera and performance, a S8 is a transparent leader here. It has a pleasing and stout construction, an overwhelming camera and a strong battery life.
But (and this is a large but), we really won’t censure we if we go for a G6. The S8 is improved and it won a many categories, true, nonetheless it isn’t so many improved than a G6. The G6 still looks and performs great, and has many of a same facilities as a S8 that make it so appealing (water resistance, slim bezels and Google Assistant). Plus, if we devise on removing a box anyway, you’re substantially not going to be hung adult about a G6’s demeanour or durability. In general, a G6 does many of what a S8 can do — nonetheless for a reduce cost tab to boot.